Most Efficient Bucket

A bucket is a truncated cone (also called frustum of a cone or a conic bowl) with open top to store stuff (mostly liquids) in it: Given constant area (side+base), what is the bucket geometry that yields maximum volume?

Let's find out by first defining some variables:
q: radius of the top, open side
r: radius of the base
h: height of the bucket
Then volume and area respectively are: V=π3h(q2+qr+r2) A=π[(q+r)h2+(qr)2+r2] We can discard the constants since we want to maximize V for constant A. From the second we can extract: h2=(Ar2q+r)2(qr)2 which can be substituted into: W=V2=h2(q2+qr+r2)2 W is a rational polynomial expression in variables q and r, so it can be maximized instead of V. Simplifying W/q=0 with WolframAlpha yields: (q+2r)(2Ar2+3q4A2)=2r3(3q2+2qr+r2) Similarly simplifying W/r=0 yields: A(2q+r)=r(q+2r)(3q+2r) Solving both for A,q (and bringing constants back) yields: q=1+72r1.823r h=74r1.627r A=π(7/2+7)r219.31r2 V=π374(7/2+7)r310.47r3 Note that side length (also called slant) is also q, and V=Ah/3. There is another nice property of this optimal bucket, can you see it?

Having golden ratio not winning this time, here is a model for your 3D printer.
Also there is an article with nice colorful plots showing the unique maxima.

No comments:

Post a Comment